Death sentence prescribed under S. 364A IPC for kidnapping for ranson not ultra vires the Constitution

Supreme Court: Deciding the matter where the question before the 3-judge bench of T.S. Thakur, R.K. Agrawal and A.K. Goel, JJ was that whether Section 364A inserted in the IPC by Act 42 of 1993 which deals with kidnapping for ranson was ultra vires the Constitution to the extent the same prescribes death sentence for anyone found guilty, the bench held that given the background in which the law was enacted and the concern shown by the Parliament for the safety and security of the citizens and the unity, sovereignty and integrity of the country, the punishment prescribed for those committing any act contrary to Section 364A cannot be dubbed as so outrageously disproportionate to the nature of the offence as to call for the same being declared unconstitutional.

Going into the legislative intent behind the said provision, the Court said that the gradual growth of the challenges posed by kidnapping and abductions for ransom, not only by ordinary criminals for monetary gain or as an organized activity for economic gains but by terrorist organizations is what necessitated the incorporation of Section 364A of the IPC and a stringent punishment for those indulging in such activities.

Stating that judicial discretion is available to Courts to choose one of the two sentences prescribed for such an offence, the Court made it clear that just because the sentence of death is a possible punishment that may be awarded in appropriate cases cannot make it per se inhuman or barbaric so as to infringe the right to life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution. Vikram Singh v. Union of India, decided on 21.08.2015

One comment

  • Death sentence is appropriate only if the Government is not fit to control the criminals, death sentence shows that Government as well as judiciary is handicap in the hands of criminal. Death sentence should be given to those criminals who can not be kept in jail, and in jails for imprisonment, they are dangerous and Govenment has no means to control them otherwise in all cases the Death sentence is barbaric for the Government as well as for the Judiciary. Death sentence in Indua is not deterrent but it excites more crime by the nears and dears of hanged criminals just like Yakub Menon, I am extremely against the "DEATH PENALITy" Request all judges to get rid off it at the most……Ved Parkash Sehtiya Advocate Mobile 9876255293. 7087754496

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

twenty + seven =